El Herradero Pocatello
El Herradero Logo

El Herradero

4.52402 reviews

El Herradero brings the vibrant flavors of Mexico to Pocatello. Nestled at 123 Jefferson Ave, it stands out with its delicious authentic dishes. This cozy spot welcomes everyone looking for a taste of Mexico. The atmosphere is relaxing, making it ideal for casual meals.

Popular for lunch and dinner, El Herradero serves specialties like carne asada fries and chicken fajitas. Its inviting décor adds to the experience. A wide selection of beers complements the menu, enhancing the dining experience. The staff at El Herradero are friendly and attentive.

About

Started as a small local eatery, El Herradero has become a beloved spot in Pocatello. It combines the rich traditions of Mexican cuisine with local influence. The restaurant's decor reflects Mexican culture, featuring vibrant colors and warm textures.

Accessibility is a highlight here. Wheelchair-friendly entrances and seating make it welcoming for all guests. The community enjoys its diverse offerings, from takeout to dining in. El Herradero's reputation for quality and service grows daily, making it a cherished gem in the area.

Get in Touch

123 Jefferson Ave, Pocatello, ID 83201, United States

Opening Hours

  • Monday 10:30-21:00
  • Tuesday 10:30-21:00
  • Wednesday 10:30-21:00
  • Thursday 10:30-21:00
  • Friday 10:30-21:00
  • Saturday 10:30-21:00
  • Sunday Closed

Where to Visit

Get Directions

Customer Reviews

"This is my favorite Mexican place in Pocatello and actually in all of Idaho. It is so so so so so good and have the best margaritas, carne asada fries, spicy pork tacos and burritos, and the best chips and salsa. Like I'm litterly drooling while writing this. The service is beyond exquisite and the staff members are always so kind."

- Zoe B.

"Paramos en este restaurante mexicano en un roadtrip de camino a Yellowstone, y fue lo mejor, comida muy rica, en buena cantidad y precios adecuados."

- Nestor G.

"I've been going to this el heroderro location for years and lately the food quality has really gone down on some of their entree's. You can tell they are trying to cut costs and save money by the taste and smell of the usual dishes. I'm actually enjoying the food at cafe rio better!"

- Samuel G.

"Has a doordash driver I picked up an order for delivery here and upon entrance the food smelled so great I had to bring the family for dinner. The service is incredible, the atmosphere is very nice! I ordered a burrito and two tacos. My wife ordered carne asada Fry's. And two tacos. My son ordered the fajita macho burrito. This at this point is my most recommend Medical restaurant in Pocatello!!!"

- D D.

"This place is 10/10 every time! Food is always great, service is excellent, and the price point is hard to beat. Most of the staff is always there and they retain their staff, which is great. We hardly ever eat out, but most of the time that we do we are headed to El Herradero."

- Tyler M.

"Love it! This place is the right combination of everything. Delicious fajitas. No blasting music. Quick service in spite of being busy. They brought us extra tortillas and sour cream, free of charge. Thank you to RadioShack for recommending El Herradero."

- Gavin G.
Write a Review

Why Visit

Visiting El Herradero means embracing authentic Mexican flavors. The carne asada is a must-try, while the chimichangas are popular among guests. Pairing them with fresh salsa elevates the experience. Prepare for a friendly atmosphere with quick service, especially during busy hours.

Lunch and dinner can get crowded, so consider visiting during off-peak hours for a more relaxed experience. Mondays and Tuesdays around 10 AM are often less busy. The lunch specials make it a great choice for students and working professionals.

The restaurant stands out for its signature margaritas and fast service. Coupled with outdoor seating options, the vibrant ambiance attracts families and groups. El Herradero's commitment to quality makes it a must-visit for anyone in the area.

Most Liked things

Customers rave about the carne asada fries; their flavor makes them a favorite. The friendly, attentive staff ensure a pleasant dining experience. Many appreciate the fresh salsa and tortillas served with meals. The warm atmosphere is also a highlight for patrons.

Most Disliked things

Some reviews mention inconsistency in food quality, which can be disappointing for regulars. A few customers have noted that certain dishes lacked the bold flavors they expected. The busy dining times may lead to a longer wait for food during peak hours.

FAQ

What type of cuisine does El Herradero serve?

El Herradero serves delicious Mexican cuisine. The menu features shrimp dishes, burritos, fajitas, and many traditional favorites. Tasty desserts round out the offerings, making it a great place for various meal types.

Is El Herradero kid-friendly?

Yes, El Herradero is very kid-friendly. The restaurant has high chairs available and a special children’s menu. The environment is relaxed, which is perfect for families.

What are the popular dishes at El Herradero?

Popular dishes include Camarones a la Diabla and the Macho Burrito. Diners also love the Chicken Fajitas. The selection of appetizers and sides adds extra flavor to every meal.

Does El Herradero offer takeout or delivery?

Yes, El Herradero provides contactless delivery, takeout options, and dine-in services. Enjoy a meal on-site, or bring it home. Convenience is key here!